Program Evaluation: James Joyce

James Joyce

Program Evaluation

18AUG1998

Program Description:
Twenty-two students and the instructor worked on Dubliners, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, Ulvsses, Finnegans Wake, and associated scholarly materials. Through seminars, small-group discussions, workshop sessions on Indo-European linguistics, presentations of Modernism in music and visual art, and the witnessing of films, we attempted to appreciate Joyce's works in themselves and to understand them in the context of earlier-twentieth-century art and thought. Writing assignments included the provision of interpretive notes on specific passages, the tracing of thematic patterns in Ulysses, and web-diagrams exploring the complexities of passages in Finnegans Wake. In addition to the discussions, presentations, and writings, each full-time student was responsible, individually or as a member of a team, for a presentation in the last week of classes of original work related to the study of Joyce. These presentations ranged from lectures summarizing research papers, through dramatic readings and musical compositions and photography, to a video production based on Ulysses.

Evaluation:
Jesse's candid and eloquent self-evaluation demonstrates how dedicated, involved, and perceptive he was in his studies - how he committed himself to the texts Joyce has left us, to pursuing research well beyond normal expectations, and to thinking/feeling his way into making the works come alive. From the outset, he understood the logic of the assignments and the purpose of all the components of the program. His teammates in his small discussion-group wrote about how energetically he maintained his focus, how much he contributed from his understanding of the Irish context, and how his bringing in of further research helped them. In turn, I found his own comments on his teammates to be mature, supportive, clear-sighted, and trustworthy. In both the small-group discussions and the seminars of the whole program, he showed great tact in dealing with his less mature, and in some cases less committed, classmates. Intent upon shaping everything which comes his way into a unified, developing world-view, he made especially good use of our studies in comparative linguistics and brought every bit of this new knowledge - phonetic relationships, mutations, and Graeco-Latinate components of English words -- to bear in the web-diagrams he devised to explicate richly difficult passages in Finnegans Wake. But all of his writing was an energetic joy to read, vigorous and thought-provoking. His tracing of the references to the "Invincibles of Phoenix Park" through Ulysses drew from me the comment: "This is an excellent job, directly responsive to the assignment and elucidating yet more of the meaningful complexity of the work." (The "creative writing" which he shared with me had its own kind of power.)

As he has said, he collaborated with three teammates in designing, writing most of the adaptations, and acting in a final project which entailed dramatization of sections of Joyce's work, mainly from A Portrait... -- carefully chosen, well prepared, well performed before an appreciative audience, and well discussed in an accompanying essay. And for the evaluation process, he submitted a reflective journal which indicated his penchant for advanced thinking-into-writing, his pressure to integrate his learning, and his being well on the way toward achieving a well-furnished mind. All in all, his performance in this program amounted to a fine job of work and left me regarding him not so much as a somewhat older student but as a somewhat younger colleague.

Suggested Course Equivalencies (in quarter hours) TOTAL: 16
* (indicates upper division credit)
*8 - Readings in the works of James Joyce
*3 - Principles of Literary Interpretation (including Advanced Expository Writing about Literature)
*3 - Introduction to Comparative Linguistics
*2 - Project: Dramatization of passages from Joyce's works